The hot water system has finally given up.
Maybe it has been running lukewarm for weeks. Maybe it is leaking from the bottom of the tank. Either way, you need a replacement, and suddenly there is a decision to make.
Do you go like for like with another electric storage system? Or is this the time to switch to a heat pump hot water system?
Most people have heard heat pumps are cheaper to run. They have also heard they cost more upfront.
Both are true. The question is which one makes more sense for your home, your budget, and the way your household uses hot water.
How Each System Heats Your Water
An electric storage system works a lot like a kettle. A heating element inside the tank heats the water and keeps it hot, ready to use.
It is simple and reliable. It is also the most common setup in Australia. According to energy.gov.au, electric storage systems are used by around 50% of Australian households and are the cheapest to buy and install, but they are generally more expensive to run.
A heat pump works more like a fridge in reverse.
Instead of heating the water directly with an element, it pulls heat from the surrounding air and transfers it into the water. Energy.gov.au notes that heat pump water heaters use 30% of the energy of a conventional electric hot water system.
That is the big difference. Same hot shower, far less electricity to make it.
Why Hot Water Matters So Much On Your Power Bill
It is easy to forget about the hot water system until it stops working.
But water heating is the second largest segment of household energy use in Australia, ranging from 15% to 30%. For a busy household with several people showering every day, that adds up across the year.
So when it is time for hot water system replacement, the choice you make will show up on every power bill for the next decade or more.
Why Logan’s Climate Suits A Heat Pump
Heat pumps work by pulling warmth out of the air. The warmer the air, the easier that job is.
That makes South East Queensland a good fit. Energy.gov.au points out that not all models are designed for locations that regularly drop below 5°C in winter. Logan’s winters are mild compared with the southern states, so a quality heat pump suits local conditions well.
A few things are still worth planning for.
The compressor makes a noise similar to an air conditioner, so the unit is best placed away from bedroom windows. It also needs good airflow around it, so a cramped, enclosed spot is not ideal.
Where Electric Storage Still Makes Sense
A heat pump is not the right answer for every home.
An electric storage system can still be the better choice if:
- you need hot water back on the same day and cannot wait for a different system to be arranged
- the upfront budget is tight right now
- it is a rental or investment property where the owner is not paying the running costs
- you already have solar panels and can heat the water during the day with your own power
- there is no suitable spot for a heat pump unit
Electric systems can also be switched to an off-peak tariff, which reduces running costs by heating water only when power is cheaper.
The key is making the choice deliberately, rather than just replacing whatever was there before because it was quickest.
What About Heat Pump Hot Water Rebates
Rebates are one of the main reasons people look at heat pumps, so it is worth knowing how they really work.
Eligible heat pumps can earn small-scale technology certificates under the federal Small-scale Renewable Energy Scheme. The Clean Energy Regulator explains that most people assign these certificates to their installer or retailer in exchange for a discount on the price.
To qualify, the system needs to be a registered model and installed by a licensed professional.
State and energy retailer rebates have come and gone over the years, so check what is available at the time you buy. A good plumber will factor any eligible heat pump hot water rebate into your quote rather than leaving you to chase it.
The Real Cost Question Is Upfront Versus Running Costs
When comparing heat pump vs electric hot water, the upfront price only tells half the story.
A heat pump generally costs more to buy and install. An electric system costs more to run. Which one comes out ahead depends on:
- how many people live in the home and how much hot water you use
- the tank size you need
- whether the new system can go in the same spot or needs changes to plumbing or electrical
- your electricity tariff and whether you have solar
- how long you plan to stay in the home
For a family home in Logan that plans to stay put for years, the lower running costs of a heat pump often make a strong case. For a short-term stay or a tight budget, electric storage may still be the practical call.
Why Logan Homeowners Choose Do Some Plumbing For Hot Water
Do Some Plumbing installs and repairs hot water systems for homes across Logan and surrounding areas, from Beenleigh and Springwood to Daisy Hill, Loganholme, and the northern Gold Coast suburbs like Arundel.
Installing a water heater is regulated plumbing work in Queensland. The QBCC lists it as work that must be done by a licensed plumber.
When you call, the team will:
- look at your household size and how you use hot water
- talk you through heat pump and electric options in plain English
- check where the new system can go and what the install involves
- give you upfront pricing with no hidden fees
And if your hot water has died completely, emergency call outs are available so you are not left with cold showers for days.
Get The Right Hot Water System The First Time
A hot water system is something you will live with for a long time.
Picking the right one now saves money on every power bill that follows. Picking the wrong one means paying for that mistake for years.
If your system is on its last legs, or has already quit, talk to Do Some Plumbing about the best replacement for your home. Find out more about our hot water installation and repairs, or get in touch here:
Frequently Asked Questions About Heat Pump And Electric Hot Water
Is a heat pump hot water system worth it in Queensland?
For many Queensland homes, yes. Heat pumps use around 30% of the energy of a conventional electric system, and South East Queensland’s mild climate suits how they work.
Are heat pump hot water systems noisy?
The compressor makes a sound similar to an air conditioner. Placing the unit away from bedroom windows and living areas usually solves the issue.
Can I get a rebate on a heat pump hot water system?
Eligible heat pumps can earn small-scale technology certificates, which are usually applied as a discount by your installer. Check the Clean Energy Regulator for details and ask about any other current offers.
How long does a hot water system replacement take?
A like-for-like replacement can often be done in a day. Switching to a heat pump may take a little longer if the plumbing or electrical needs to be changed.
Can I replace my electric hot water system with a heat pump?
In most homes, yes. A plumber will check the available space, airflow, and connections to make sure a heat pump will work well in your chosen spot.






